Did you catch President Obama’s commencement speech at Arizona State University the other day?
Me neither, and I don’t blame you: watching his head bob back and forth between teleprompters (which shake and smolder from overuse) is an activity that gets old faster than raw fish (and is about as malodorous).
But if you listen to the advice the President and First Lady give to the youth of America, you will learn that they’re through with America as it has been. His ascension marks a Year Zero, after which the country (which he inherited!) is “remade” (how often does he use that word?).
First, the President:
Now, some graduating classes have marched into this stadium in easy times - times of peace and stability when we call on our graduates to simply keep things going, and not screw it up. Other classes have received their diplomas in times of trial and upheaval, when the very foundations of our lives have been shaken, the old ideas and institutions have crumbled, and a new generation is called on to remake the world.
“Remake the world”—what did I tell you! The messianic complex is yours, B-HO; don’t project it on everyone else.
Anyway, it’s easy to see where this is going:
It should be clear by now the category into which all of you fall. For we gather here tonight in times of extraordinary difficulty, for the nation and the world. The economy remains in the midst of a historic recession, the result, in part, of greed and irresponsibility that rippled out from Wall Street and Washington, as we spent beyond our means and failed to make hard choices.
…
For many of you, these challenges are felt in more personal terms. Perhaps you’re still looking for a job - or struggling to figure out what career path makes sense in this economy. Maybe you’ve got student loans, or credit card debts, and are wondering how you’ll ever pay them off. Maybe you’ve got a family to raise, and are wondering how you’ll ensure that your kids have the same opportunities you’ve had to get an education and pursue their dreams.
In the face of these challenges, it may be tempting to fall back on the formulas for success that have dominated these recent years. Many of you have been taught to chase after the usual brass rings: being on this “who’s who” list or that top 100 list; how much money you make and how big your corner office is; whether you have a fancy enough title or a nice enough car.
Well, a job would be nice. These kids have invested four years (and tens of thousands of dollars) to learn a trade, or in some way to prepare themselves to join the world (not “remake” it) of workers, doers, creators—and he’s making them feel like Oliver Twist asking for more gruel.
I think I know what he’s trying to say, but the “formulas for success” he disparages have been remarkably successful. The current recession included, isn’t the American economy a success story beyond imagining and belief?
Guess not:
I want to highlight two main problems with that old approach. First, it distracts you from what is truly important, and may lead you to compromise your values, principles and commitments. Think about it. It’s in chasing titles and status - in worrying about the next election rather than the national interest and the interests of those they represent - that politicians so often lose their way in Washington. It was in pursuit of gaudy short-term profits, and the bonuses that come with them, that so many folks lost their way on Wall Street.
The leaders we revere, the businesses that last - they are not the result of narrow pursuit of popularity or personal advancement, but of devotion to some bigger purpose - the preservation of the Union or the determination to lift a country out of depression; the creation of a quality product or a commitment to your customers, your workers, your shareholders and your community.
Oh yeah, that describes Nancy Pelosi and Bill Gates to a T.
What is Obama talking about?
Let me repeat my belief: capitalism is an engine, an enormously powerful engine that has no equal in HP, torque, compression, etc. But it has no steering wheel, no ability to choose direction. The role of government is to guide, as lightly and as effortlessly as possible, that engine in the direction that most benefits its people. But it is as foolish to sit in your car with the engine off, wondering why it doesn’t go when you turn the wheel, as it is to expect the government to be able to fuel and run the economy. Or to expect it (the car or the economy) to have a moral sense.
But here’s Obama trying to make the sale, close the deal:
With a degree from this university, you have everything you need to get started. Did you study business? Why not help our struggling non-profits find better, more effective ways to serve folks in need. Nursing? Understaffed clinics and hospitals across this country are desperate for your help. Education? Teach in a high-need school; give a chance to kids we can’t afford to give up on - prepare them to compete for any job anywhere in the world. Engineering? Help us lead a green revolution, developing new sources of clean energy that will power our economy and preserve our planet.
Or you can make your mark in smaller, more individual ways. That’s what so many of you have already done during your time here at ASU - tutoring children; registering voters; doing your own small part to fight hunger and homelessness, AIDS and cancer. I think one student said it best when she spoke about her senior engineering project building medical devices for people with disabilities in a village in Africa. Her professor showed a video of the folks they’d be helping, and she said, “When we saw the people on the videos, we began to feel a connection to them. It made us want to be successful for them.”
Which is more than you have done, Mr. President.

I have no quarrel with any of his suggestions: who could? But what if it is your bliss to become the best heart surgeon there is, widening the aortas of the rich and famous? Is that so bad? Or becoming a lawyer to defend Dow Chemical in a class action suit? Isn’t that how our system works? If everyone taught in a “high-need” school (as he seems to suggest), who would teach the spoiled little snots in the fancy private schools?
The contributions of everyone should be celebrated: business baron and community organizer. Where the hell do you think the money is going to come from if everyone works with disabled Africans (as Obama himself has never done)?
I have been a liberal, and I have been a conservative, and I was no more generous as an enlightened lefty than I am as a neanderthal. Statistics repeatedly prove the opposite is more generally true. Certainly, our own president’s personal history does.
But he’s made his point.
Now, what about his old lady?
First lady Michelle Obama praised graduating students at California’s smallest, youngest public university for their determination to succeed, urging them to give back to their communities with the same fervor they showed to bring her to campus.
…
“Many of you may be considering leaving town with your diploma in hand, and it wouldn’t be unreasonable,” Mrs. Obama said before a crowd of 12,000 wilting in the blazing afternoon sun. “By using what you’ve learned here you can shorten the path perhaps for kids who may not see a path at all. I was once one of those kids.”
…
“You will face tough times. You will certainly have doubts, and let me tell you because I know I did when I was your age,” she said. “Remember that you are blessed. Remember that in exchange for those blessings, you must give something back. You must reach back and pull someone up. You must bend down and let someone else stand on your shoulders so that they can see a brighter future.”
Now, that’s not bad. At least she doesn’t shame them for wanting to succeed.
(One more line from her husband: “The trappings of success may be a by-product of this larger mission, but they can’t be the central thing. Just ask Bernie Madoff.” Honest to God, Barack, give it a rest.)
But is that all it was to these graduates—just show up and receive their “blessings”? Did no one do any work? (This is a California state school, so maybe not.)
I am going to make a statement as broad and generalized as anything quoted above: some of these graduates worked a hell of a lot harder, and brought themselves a hell of a lot further, than did either Barack or Michelle Obama. And they did so to make something of themselves, not to make something of someone else (as if they even could).
Why are liberals so closed-minded about ways to “give back”? I was. Now, I think Steve Jobs, or Donald Trump, or even Bernie Madoff does more to bring along the disadvantaged than any ACORN activist or homeless advocate (well, maybe not Bernie).
To the graduates of Bloodthirstan Technical School, Class or 2009, I say this: the world somehow survived this long without you. It’s not perfect, but then it never was—its thermostat is shot to hell, alternately freezing up solid and melting into a puddle; it’s misshapen, not a perfect sphere, but wider at the equator; periodically, life here gets wiped out by cataclysmic impacts with comets and asteroids. You are welcome to join us. There is no bouncer, no dress code—no open bar—no ticket required. You can dance with the one that brung you, or you can go home with the hot blond (male, female, or both). Just find a spot on the dance floor and shake what your mama gave you. It’ll have to do.